Hypothetical question: organ transplants.

This is a purely hypothetical question and is not based on any current (Allah la ye2adar) events.  If you could donate an organ like a kidney to your mom, dad, spouse, child, sibling or best friend; would you?  I say kidney because my assumption is that you are not dead, you have two of them and you really only need one and you can make that decision while you are alive.  Would you choose to give them a couple of years/months more for them to live?  If you are already dead then this question does not apply, but do you have the ability to let go of your own kidney just to try to help someone else?  And the bigger question is, could you do that knowing that the organ might be rejected and you would have lost a kidney in vain?  your special person would have to go through the rest of their life on medication to prevent the rejection of that organ, they would always have low immunity and other general unpleasantness?

Which is more merciful?  To help them enjoy what is left as much as possible or to give them more time but one that might not be as enjoyable?


  • At 2008.10.18 19:51, mona said:

    Wow, that’s a tough one, I don’t know which is more merciful. I wouldn’t care about losing a kidney “in vain” but at least I tried.

    • At 2008.10.18 21:31, Qwaider قويدر said:

      If it’s for a loved one, I wouldn’t give it a moment’s thought. Even if there’s a chance that it will be rejected

      • […] Del.icio.us Jessyz Just Imagine: The future of nature – Stories and Video from CNN.com InternationalBreaking micro addictions – wallpaper style. | Chocolate Mints In a JarWhat will your kids remember about you?Wandering Scarab: Divorce in Egypt20 Best Websites To Download Free E-Booksyoungmuslimmother.comChocolate Mints in a jar ← Hypothetical question: organ transplants. […]

        • At 2008.10.22 14:14, Solace said:

          I would go for it. If it is rejected I would know I did the best I could.